
Had a chance to shoot for a couple hours this weekend for a good friend of ours. Eileen Rothe is a fantastic singer/songwriter and she, ahem, walks it like she rocks it. She’s also a riot to shoot with. There’s something to be said for clients who trust you. Pressure goes down, creativity goes up, and work seems like play again.

This shoot was my first shoot with the 5D MK II and I love, LOVE this camera. It’s such a pleasure to use, the new menus make it faster to get to settings like WB and ISO, and the look is as film-like as the 5D, only more so. I shot on manual exposure, and custom WB so I don’t have much to say about the AE or AWB but from the playing-around I did the other day they seem as good as, or better than, the 5D, and I never had a complaint about them then. Most of you know I’m no pixel-peeper, so this is nothing more than a gushing reaction. I’m pretty sure you can find all kinds of tech talk elsewhere.
Do I love the camera? Absolutely. Will I be selling my old 5D bodies? I doubt it. Will I be taking it around the world with me in 12 days? I doubt that too. First, there are no spare batteries anywhere on the continent so I’d be traveling with one battery. That’s crazy talk. Secondly, the files are MASSIVE. I knew they would be – not only are they bigger, but also deeper – 21 megapixels at 14bits. So the files will fill my drives faster, take WAY longer to download, and WAY longer to convert to DNG, process, etc. I know I can choose to shoot smaller files, but that’s the rub. For my travel – until I get more RAM and larger drives, the file options are a little too big or a little too small. A RAW option that sat right in the middle, say about the file size of the old 5D, that would have been perfect. Would I suggest you all rush out and buy a 5D Mk2? Nope. Bang for the buck for many, many photographers right now will be better off snapping up a good used 5D body and some great optics. Think about it – for the what I paid for the MkII body I could have bought a used 5D body AND an 85/1.2L lens.
Why did I buy the MkII? First, my 5D bodies are both 3 years old and bound to fail (again) at some point. Seemed like a good idea. Bigger files size when I need it. Better weather sealing. Better low-light performance. The new 3 inch LCD is nice too (the size is nice but the better colour-fidelity is AWESOME. Finally, my images don’t look like crap on the LCD.) But, if the 5D MkII hadn’t come out for another year, truth is I’d be just as happy shooting with my current 5D bodies. Think about this one before you shell out. For many shooters it’s just more camera than you need. If you need full-frame – and who doesn’t? – then a good used 5D and some sweet glass, would be a wise choice. There’s much to be said for staying on the trailing edge of technology, and you can snap up 5D bodies pretty cheap right now. I’d buy a used 5D over a new 50D right now – that’s how much I love the 5D and all it’s full-framed goodness.

The 5D MkII is just the right upgrade for me – larger files that my commercial and stock clients will like, and ergonomics that are familiar to me and require no new learning. What would make it perfect? I have no need for the video functions and would love to have traded that for more file-size options. I hate that I need new batteries for this thing, but once I’ve bought them and stopped my whining I’m pretty sure I’m going to love the longer life and smarter technology.
Ben Wilmore has a more thorough reaction to the MkII on his blog HERE and he mentions a bunch of things I just plain forgot.
Anyways, those are my initial thoughts. Tomorrow is Christmas Eve, and as it happens, my birthday. Then it’s Christmas. These are important days of faith for me – not sacred days per se, but days to focus on the sacred. I’ll be posting a pre-published post tomorrow, then back on the 26th.
The images of Eileen were taken with my 5D MkII, 85/1.2L wide open, and a 5ft Elinchrom Octobox.